20 May 2010

Homophobia in football

And this is the reason we have not progressed with the acceptance and appreciation of diversity that 2010 should hold.

Footballer, Jason Akermanis's opinion piece in today's Herald Sun.

I don't like football. Don't follow it. Don't have a team. Would rather it not be a part of my Melbourne life, but it seems unavoidable.

This opinion piece confirms my belief that footballers should stick to doing what they do best. Kicking balls on the field. Not have media careers unless they are going to offer a constructive and intelligent opinion.

Jason Akermanis believes that gay footballers should remain 'in the closet' because it could be detrimental to the football team. He does not think the football world is ready to accept homosexuality. And he admits to feeling uncomfortable around gay footballers in the change rooms.

'If you thought suicide was bad among young men, it is four to six times higher for people who are attracted to the same sex. It clearly can be a difficult and lonely road, one that hopefully can be made easier.

Now try being the first AFL player to come out. That is too big a burden for any player.'

Not only has Akermanis failed to mention the sources of his sketchy 'facts', but he hasn't made things any easier for gay footballers to come out. Not even when he says that he hopes things can be made easier for them.

I can sort of see his point, though it seems to be located in a really dim lit room full of cliches and testosterone, nudge nudge, wink winks and college jockery. The point I can sort of see is Akermanis's warning to gay footballers not to admit to being gay.

I can only sort of see his point from the perspective that coming out in the type of environment that Akermanis fosters through his narrow minded views would be detrimental to the emotional health and security of said footballers.

He suggests that the coming out of a high profile footballer would make international news and 'could break the fabric of the club'.

If the club had any fabric, it would be supportive and accepting. It shouldn't be a big deal. It shouldn't be an issue for the team. If anything, the team spirit created through support should be encouraging, respectful and promoting of inclusion, no matter sexual orientation.

Workplace diversity is such an important issue. And anti-discrimination is a legal issue. Why should the principles of workplace diversity not apply to a football team? I believe the football team is the footballer's workplace. There is a disparity here. Particularly when there has been a number of cases where footballers have been suspended or sacked from their team, or criminally charged for serious incidents in their private life that have been before the courts.

I have heard of football codes taking part in training programs about how to treat women respectfully. Could there be some sort of training program to tell them that homosexuality is ok and homophobia is not ok?

I imagine it would be so difficult to have to suppress your true self through fear of ramifications. Message to Akermanis and other footballers and the general public who share this view: coming out does not mean that homosexuality will be flaunted or become contagious.

If Akermanis is not given a speaking to by his team and the AFL chiefs about his homophobic attitude in addition to the dressing downs he has already received from community groups and the media - Crikey and Jack Marx have given good rebuttal, then maybe he should spend some time with one of the fantastic homosexuality support groups being run in Melbourne schools.

When I was 20 and living in a small town, I went shopping with my good friend to buy a present for his then boyfriend's 21st birthday. He wanted to buy his boyfriend a ring. I pretended to look for a ring for MY boyfriend, and said that I had my friend there to give his opinion. We often laugh about the whole experience because I didn't get my story straight from the outset, and at one jeweller, the sales assistant asked whether 'my' boyfriend liked silver or gold. I didn't know. 'Silver', my friend blurted out. It was a fun trip, all of our shopping trips were fun, but when I think back, we should't have had to shop under any guise. My friend should have been able to buy a ring for his boyfriend with no judgement or stigma.

In my opinion, when high profile gay people come out, it reduces the stigma surrounding homosexuality and may reassure gay people that it's ok to come out and be themselves. I can think of a number of high profile people who have come out, or have been openly gay since the start of their celebrity status, that have said that it's made a difference to their fans – gay or not. Ruby Rose. Daniel Kowalski. Darren Hayes. Beth Ditto. Adam Lambert.

Akermanis says, 'We have made massive steps in other areas of society and in time I hope the environment changes to a degree where coming out isn't a big deal.'

Well, this opinion piece has just confirmed that the environment will continue to be difficult for gay footballers, and that coming out will remain a big deal, because of the attitude and prejudices conveyed.

Victoria University released a report about homophobia in sport today. You can view a press release with a link to the full report here.


  1. great blog post and i think you have lots of points.. but have to disagree with you on 'footballers should stick to do doing what they best. Kicking balls on the field' Not all footballers are big mouthed ignorant idiots like Jason, in fact we suffered his idiocies and big mouth for a long time in brisbane. Trust me when i say alot of footballers will be shaking their heads. Like with anything it only takes 1 moron to ruin something and make everyone involved look silly.
    Afl in general doesnt condone things like this and i would safely say he will be getting a talking to. Nrl , well theres a sport where rape, drugs, alcohol, homophobia, and general stupid behaviour is condoned...

    anyways hope youve had a good week.

    danielle x

  2. Great point you make Danielle. Perhaps I should not have made that generalisation - not all footballers think the same.

  3. Great post Carly - I couldn't agree more... Well said (and written) x

  4. Carls, do not let the negative comment get you down!!! Stay strong xxxxxx

  5. Wonderfully written post Carly!

    I actually watched an AFL show with the boy last night and they were discussing this article.

    I was actually suprised that they were 110% against what Akermanis did and believe he did it to help himself because his career in football is almost done and doing things like this might help his media career. I doubt that it will help him at all

  6. What an interesting story. I think it's so sad that in this day and age, people who don't swim in the mainstream are still treated like 2nd class citizens. I think we all think we live in this world that's so much more progressive than it was 50 or 100 years ago, but the same prejudices still exist, they are just more under the surface. My brother is gay so these kinds of issues just make me so angry

  7. i wasnt making a negative comment but anyways :) i was simply saying, not all footballers think that way.


Thank you for reading my blog. I love receiving comments :)
I really appreciate the time you've taken to write to me, and to share something about yourself.


Related Posts with Thumbnails