Showing posts with label Beauty and the Beast - The Ugly Face of Prejudice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Beauty and the Beast - The Ugly Face of Prejudice. Show all posts

13 April 2011

Reflections of an unfamiliar face - guest post by Elle

Last year I shared Elle's beautiful words with you. She wrote about not being able to blend into a crowd. I identified with so many of her experiences - the stares, looks of pity, fearing drunk peoples' reactions. Elle was born with severe facial deformities which impacted so much more than her physical appearance. 


Elle and I have become friends through blogging. She identified with my stories and told me hers. We've never met but I've never even considered her appearance as being anything different to her beautiful and courageous words. 

She let me share this piece of writing from her blog.

[reflections of an unfamiliar face]

"Eleven years ago today, I had a six and a half hour operation and woke up with a different face. Well, I woke up with an incredibly swollen blackandblue face that I came to know for a few weeks and never saw again, really. I always say that operation made me want to die, but saved my life.

I recently finally got around to watching Beauty & the Beast: The Ugly Face of Prejudice, Episode 3 which has a 32-year old man with Treacher Collins in it. I literally grew up around people that had facial deformities. Not in terms of my family or friends; none of them even had medical problems other than one friend with asthma and her brother with kidney problems. But in terms of where I spent a lot of my time, the Cleft Lip & Palate/Cranio-Maxillo-Facial unit of the only children's hospital here. The kind of faces people stare at in the street was always normal to me, long before I even realised I had one myself. That's why listening to the "beauty" in this episode talk about her first meeting with the guy with TCS freaked me out. I don't know what life is like without thinking faces like that are normal, instead of scary and confusing like it obviously was for her.

The kids that I saw, older and younger than me, better and worse deformities than me, made me feel less alone. I never really talked to them, I was far too shy for that. But I felt like we were all in this together. It didn't matter what our diagnosis or severity was. Treacher Collins, Pierre Robin, hemifacial microsomia, Goldenhar, Apert. None of those names mattered to me. I doubt they mattered to any of us. What difference did it make? When I was born, it was Pierre Robin. When I moved to the United States, they said Goldenhar. I moved back here and it became and stayed at hemifacial microsomia. This is a term I still maintain is just something they call people that don't quite fit so perfectly into the other craniofacial syndromes. I had more shit wrong with me than Pierre Robin kids; I didn't have the eye diseases that Goldenhar had. And for some reason they never seemed to think I had Treacher Collins. One side is slightly worse than the other, so hemifacial microsomia will do. Only as I got older and understood the very big genetic difference between HFM and TCS did I care.

I felt lucky a lot as a kid. I had bones missing from my face, my lower jaw set back from my upper jaw, a cleft palate and major speech problems, non-existent ear canals and a hearing loss, a thumb that doesn’t bend, hips that were dislocated at birth, and strabismus that turned into amblyopia (so my brain only registers signals sent from my left eye, not my right). But some of those kids were so much worse than me. So I felt lucky. When I was doing my undergraduate degree a few years ago, my best friend from uni and I did an internship at that hospital unit. We spoke to the kids and wanted to find out what they like and what they would change about the CLP/CMF clinic. It was a big survey and report we did, thanks to my ex-doctor allowing us to be there and helping us out. My friend was and is one of the kindest, loveliest people I have ever known and I could see even she was taken aback by some of the kids there. Some of the faces. She cried in the car in front of me after the first day, about them and about me, about what they would go through and what I went through. I think because of that experience of spending a few weeks there, despite the fact that she never knew me growing up, she understands that aspect of my life better than most.

I was very lucky in primary school; I grew up around the kids I went to school with from the age of six so they never saw anything wrong with my face. It was just me and the fact that I was always absent from school for doctor's appointments and hospital stays was just me, too. I got a little teased when I got hearing aids, but mostly it was okay. I met my (main) craniofacial/plastic surgeon when I was seven. He was technically my third plastic surgeon; one repaired my cleft palate when I was a  baby and another did further palate surgery in Denver. He always asked me about school and the kids and the way people treated me. (In a very vague, roundabout child-like way that I didn't understand what he was getting at until I was older. I recall telling him about my best friend and I playing our Sweet Valley acting game.) Surgery on my face was just an option for the future when I was in primary school. (The three cleft palate repairs, trying to correct the strabismus in my eyes, the eight sets of grommets and numerous eardrum repairs were not so much an option.) My choice in primary school was always: no surgery. It was something all the doctors got together and talked about, talked with me, talked with my parents, but in my head - it was not going to happen. They were not going to cut around my skull and take my face off, so they could move my cheekbones and jaw forward. No way. Why on earth would I have that done?

Then it began to change. I realised, fully, when I was in my last year or two of primary school that my face looked different. I realised my mum had these huge cheekbones that just never grew for me and how weird my jaw looked when I looked at myself in the mirror side-on. But still, it didn't feel like the end of the world. It could be worse, right? No one else seemed to care. But then I entered high school and the, “Hey freak, what happened to your face?” happened on the first day and that being-hit-in-the-stomach-going-to-throw-up feeling when I realised he was talking to me, and things went rapidly downhill. My doctor continued to ask about the kids at school, the people in the street. I told my surgeon about the teasing to a degree. I told him what they said to me every day. It got a lot worse. The kids in my year. The ones in the year above. The guys in Year 12 in my tutor group. He asked and he asked. I wanted to die. I hated my face. I was terrified of my life being like this. I was growing, but my jaw wasn’t and my cheekbones definitely weren’t. My jaw was aching when I talked for too long and I took forever to eat. Two years of this, I made the decision, myself, to have surgery. My doctor wanted me to wait. He tried to convince me to at least wait another year, so I was closer to being fully grown. I couldn’t do it. I was constantly crying in appointments with him, with my ENT, with my mum. Even though I still didn’t tell them or anyone the full extent of what was happening at school because I didn’t want to upset them. I think he knew I couldn’t have dealt with the operation they always talked about, so he made a smaller one. And I did it, a few weeks after I turned 15. They were the most horrific weeks of my life (although my first ear canal reconstruction was almost on par and took longer to recover from), but I don’t regret it. I still get stared at and I still get comments and my doctor told me this would happen and prepared me for it. But I don’t hate my face and I don’t want to die, so how could it be anything but completely worth it? And people that judge me, or anyone, for opting to have surgery make me want to scream. You’re as bad as the people that judge me for my face. People that say crap about plastic surgeons should meet the ones that help these kids. Should meet the ones that go to the third world countries and repair cleft lips and palates.

I would like to be one of those people that seem to just be able to move past it. The stares and comments barely cause me to blink 90% of the time these days. But I don’t think I will move past it. It was my life. Even though I only see my ENT these days, I still think of it as being a big part of my life. I do, honestly, just wish I could sit at that hospital in that clinic and meet every one of the kids that go through there. I want to be able to help them, be someone to talk to that actually understands what it’s like, to tell them they will make it through this pain and recovery and teasing and survive. That’s all I ever wanted when I was going through it. Someone that had my face and knew what it was like and would tell me how they survived. Tell me that I would survive."

16 March 2011

On vanity, prejudice and beauty (part 2)

Thank you for the discussion around my first vanity, prejudice and beauty entry. Glad I got you thinking and talking about the issue.

Today's continuation of the topic is around the idea of cures. The desire for a cure often comes from someone without the disability or disfigurement.

There is an attitude that surgery is a quick and necessary fix for disabilities and disfigurements. I've had people tell me they couldn't possibly look like me, and would definitely have surgery if they did. Often surgery is not an option (or wanted) by the person with the disability or disfigurement. And the quick fix of surgery won't help change peoples' attitudes and prejudices. I actually regard this attitude as vanity.

 (source)
Britain has a wonderful initiative called Changing Faces Campaign. Its website states:

“It’s not just about surgery.”

Changing Faces is the leading UK charity that supports and represents people who have disfigurements to the face, hand or body from any cause.

We live in a culture where disfigurement is often seen as a medical “problem” that could/should be fixed by surgery or medical intervention. However, surgery alone cannot always remove a disfigurement and can sometimes lead to further complications. Changing Faces helps people to face the challenges of living with a disfigurement and equips them with the appropriate tools to build self-confidence and self-esteem.

The psychological effects of disfigurement whether acquired from birth, an accident, disease or the aftermath of surgery can last a lifetime if not dealt with early on.

Our work involves:
1. Providing support for children, young people, adults and their families through our counselling services to help with the psychological and social aspects of disfigurement.
2. Working with schools & employers to ensure a culture of inclusion, and with health and social care professionals to provide better psychological care for people with disfigurements.
3. Campaigning for better policies and practices that are inclusive of people with disfigurements and for social change by working with the media, government and opinion leaders.
The Changing Faces Campaign is so important in creating awareness. We've got to start talking more about reducing prejudice against appearance, and value diversity, and know that beauty isn't just  a perfect image.

I wrote and starred in a number of sketches for No Limits. They are all based on true situations that have happened to me. I am pretty proud of them. These two are about cures.


That first one is in reference to the faith 'healers' that have approached me, insisting they can cure me. Not having a bar of it. So many of them have told me how unfortunate it is that I look this way. Unfortunate for them, because it makes them uncomfortable? Or unfortunate for me because this illness can be really difficult?


And that second one is more about the expectation by others that we should conform to looking 'normal'. Yes, that really happened to me, in a lift at work, and yes, I was gobsmacked!!

I have noticed that some people get so uncomfortable when they notice me, and their own insecurities show. Lots of people see me and then quickly look away, or just blurt out blunders like in those sketches.

Personally, I don't want a cure. While being without ichthyosis would be more convenient, the side effects are too high. I can't speak for others with disabilities and disfigurements, but through discussions on the cures episode of No Limits, there were questions whether cures will leave us better off, and the judgement that our disabilities are a deficit.

I think the idea and desire for perfection - media, magazines, airbrushing, the cosmetic (surgery and makeup) industry - can make it very easy for people to judge those with disabilities and disfigurements. Media,  magazines, airbrushing, the cosmetic industry are all quick fixes to a perfect image. And so people think there should be a quick fix - cure or operation - for those who they regard as looking less perfect than the ideal.

I really hope you continue discussing this issue. I am so passionate about this - please spread the word! And stay tuned for the final part of this series. Thanks for reading!

08 March 2011

On vanity, prejudice and beauty (part 1)


A friend recently asked me why I take so much pride in what I wear and love fashion so much when I dislike me and others being judged on appearances An interesting question.

As I wrote on DiVine, and then Mamamia, my dad once told me that I should always take pride in myself. He said I should always present myself in the best way possible. I should be well dressed and groomed. Walk with good posture. Always smile. Be a nice person. He told me this because he believed it would help people look past my confronting chronic illness.
I love fashion as much as the next girl. And I enjoy being photographed - you can probably tell from the amount of photos I post of myself here. I don't follow trends religiously, and know I'm not supercool, but I love flicking through fashion magazines and blogs, and shopping is my religion. Sometimes I plan my outfits like someone would plan an important project - I probably devote far too much time on thinking about clothes. But dressing well makes me feel good, and I also receive lots of compliments. And what woman doesn't want that? A pretty dress can take my mind off my scaly scalp. And wearing a nice outfit after a week of hanging in my trackies while off work sick is a great pick me up. And dressing well also makes me feel like others are looking past my redness - and seeing me for my personality, interests and creativity.

I don't think my interest in fashion and yearning to dress well is vanity. I hate that trait. To me, vanity is ugly.
I hate the homogenisation of image, and the need to look perfect at all times - just like the models in magazines. People look the same - and fear difference. They associate bad looks with failure. But I think individuality is beautiful. Why would you want to look like everyone else?

When people start talking about how ugly they look in person or photos, or talk about their bad hair-day or minute pimple, I tune out. Boring. Superficiality is boring. As I wrote the other day, I hate the fishing for compliments when they post 'bad' pictures of themselves online. I regard it as self obsessed, insecure and disrespectful to greater issues. It's like they think their looks are the only thing they have going for them. Well, in some cases, it may well be...

Get this - I was once told that I wouldn't know what it's like to be teased because I'm beautiful. Because this woman was teased because she was beautiful. I know. Difficult times. Because it's not like I know what it's like to be teased because of my appearance. (And as karma would have it, the person who said this to me is in an extremely bad place now, a place I wouldn't wish on anyone.)

Call me harsh, but in all honesty I can't fathom the comparisons 'beautiful people' make between the ridicule they receive compared to the insults people with disabilities and disfigurements receive. It may be naive or small minded, or perhaps judgemental of me, but I don't get these comparisons. I don't get the desire to change image 'for the better' through surgery or cosmetic treatments. And perhaps by my commentary here, I am being judgemental towards those genetically blessed people.

I recently saw a video of the UK TV documentary/reality TV show Beauty and the Beast - The Ugly Face of Prejudice. While I completely disagree with the term 'beast' used about someone's appearance, I agree with the premise of the show, and need to showcase the reality (if a reality TV show can be deemed a reality) of the prejudices faced by people with disabilities and disfigurements, and changing peoples' perceptions and value of appearance.

Beauty and the Beast pairs up self obsessed, vain beauties with people born with disabilities or acquired disfigurements, and helps the 'beauty' do away with the importance placed on image.
Hosted by Adam Pearson, the show deals with the invisibility felt by people with disabilities or disfigurements, and discrimination experienced - surprisingly by both the pair. Discrimination due to image is just as difficult as discrimination due to inaccessibility. One of the most important statements in the show is "Imagine if I'd been turned away because I was black, or I simply just wasn't good looking enough? Where do you draw the line on discrimination by looks?"

There are no YouTube videos of the show that can be embedded on my blog, but you can watch the videos from here. I really felt moved by this video - the interaction between Leo and Yasmin.
But there is a good vlog providing a commentary of Beauty and the Best that I want to share:

Great thoughts, Mike. And I can hear Savage Garden in the background!

While I haven't been obviously directly discriminated on due to my appearance, I'm sure it's happened. Maybe I didn't get a job because there was a perception I'd be too much of a liability. I have certainly been told that it's great I'm out in public and not locked away somewhere.

And of course, there's the staring and comments. Sometimes I position myself facing away from people - particularly kids - at cafes, just to avoid being stared and pointed at in public.

I often tire of peoples' vanity. I once told someone who didn't want a photo taken of themselves due to a bad hair day that "if I can be ok with my appearance after being called ugly by a group of five dwarfs in public, then you can be ok with yours".

Yep, I'm always telling it as it is. Hopefully to make people realise that looking good isn't everything.

There's more of this that I want to cover - but I've written heaps here, so look out for future blog entries continuing the topic.

I am so passionate about this topic - please spread the word!

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails